“Blood” (PRP) Versus “Gel” (Hyaluronic Acid) Injections: How to Choose
/The two most popular and common injections we offer patients for knee osteoarthritis are platelet-rich plasma (PRP), utilizing a patient’s own blood, and hyaluronic acid injections, commonly known as the gel, rooster comb, or viscosupplement injections.
Let’s compare the two and discuss pros and cons of each:
Both would be considered “natural“ injections with PRP obviously coming from your own blood and hyaluronic acid is a substance already in your joint, but depleted in joints that have osteoarthritis.
We often describe PRP as that big 100,000 mile service you do on your car, and hyaluronic injections are more like the oil change. Thus, PRP is more comprehensive.
PRP Injections
PROS
-most effective long-term injection we offer patients. Benefits typically seen for 6–24 months, and then PRP can then be safely repeated when necessary.
-very likely disease–modifying, meaning we are stopping or slowing the deterioration of cartilage in the knee. These give patients the greatest opportunity to either delay or avoid knee replacement.
-other than weight loss, probably the best long-term medical and financial nonsurgical investment in the health of your knee.
CONS
-not covered by insurance. See our blog regarding this here
-works gradually, with greatest benefit likely seen 4-6 months after the injections.
-anti-inflammatories of any type as well as blood thinners need to be stopped before and after the PRP procedure for a specific period of time.
Hyaluronic acid Injections
PROS
-authorized by most insurance plans, meaning the cost of these is fully covered, partially covered, or can be applied towards your deductible.
-excellent safety profile.
-the majority of patients see a benefit, often for 4 to 12 months.
-like PRP, injections are not particularly painful when given into the knee joint under ultrasound guidance and only require a few days of rest afterwards.
CONS
-may have an indirect benefit on the long-term health of the knee joint, but are not considered “disease–modifying” like PRP.
-benefits of pain and swelling reduction along with functional improvements do not last as long as PRP.
-although they work a bit more rapidly than PRP injections, typically it takes 6 to 8 weeks after the final injection to see the greatest benefit.
-most brands require a series of 3–4 total injections, given one per week.
Want to know more about PRP?
Learn about the key details of PRP here
How is PRP simple and not-so-simple? Read here
As always, let us know if we can be of assistance to you!
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
Orthopedic Injections: What Not To Do
/Injections are one of the most commonly used interventions in an orthopedic practice. Yet, where, how and what is injected is of vital importance, and certain approaches are just not in the best interest of the patient. Here are injections we prefer you avoid:
1) Injections for musculoskeletal conditions given in a chiropractic or primary care office. Both chiropractors, chiropractic mid-levels (NPs and PAs) along with PCPs all often do a great job in their respective specialties. However, giving injections optimally is just not in their wheelhouse. Therefore, if an injection is needed or suggested, then seek the expertise of an orthopedic specialist.
2) Receive a series of steroid injections for soft tissue conditions, such as plantar fasciitis, tennis/golfer’s elbow or gluteal tendinopathy (often mislabeled as “hip bursitis”). We often use the statement, “better in the short term, worse in the long-term.” This really applies to situations when multiple steroid injections are given in a short period of time, as they ultimately can lead to further breakdown and tearing of these tendons/fascia.
3) Receive a steroid injection for Achilles, patellar or quadriceps tendon problems. These tendons are much higher risk for rupture, especially if exposed to a steroid injection. If anyone suggests a steroid for one of these conditions, then RUN (figuratively)!
4) Pay top dollar for an orthobiologic injection such as platelet-rich plasma (PRP) without ultrasound guidance. It’s your choice to have this injection if it’s non-guided but just realize that accuracy is so important with this type of injection. There is no way to ensure the solution is making it to the intended area without ultrasound.
5) Receive “stem cell” injections that do not come from your own tissue. If a stem cell injection is being suggested, it should be derived from your bone marrow or your adipose (fat) tissue. Most of these products "ordered for you” do not actually contain any live stem cells, and at this point, are not approved by the FDA for usage in musculoskeletal conditions.
As always, let us know if we can help you!
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
PRP: The Details Matter. Give Us 3 Minutes
/More practices than ever are offering platelet-rich plasma (PRP) injections to their patients, especially those with osteoarthritis, tennis and golfer’s elbow, partial rotator cuff tears, Achilles and patellar tendonopathy and plantar fasciitis, just to name a few.
We often say, “not all PRP is the same.” There are so many details that go into the success rate of the injections. On that subject, how do you define success? Less pain, better function, healing of damaged tissue and/or the slowing of the deterioration of cartilage, especially in osteoarthritis. PRP can truly be a disease-modifying treatment, not just something to make you temporarily feel better.
Now, what details really matter?
Experience of the physician: how long has he/she been giving PRP injections
Accuracy of the injection: ultrasound-guidance is paramount
Amount of blood used to produce the PRP: we’ve learned that a higher volume of blood is likely necessary to produce the optimal number of platelets
Creation of the PRP: constructing the optimal amount of PRP to inject for each condition. Creating a mixture either rich in leukocytes (white blood cells) or poor in leukocytes
Providing the best recommendations regarding what medications and supplements should be temporarily stopped before and after the injections
Providing the best recommendations regarding restrictions (use of a boot, crutches, bracing, type of rest) after the PRP
Deciding upon the optimal number and frequency of injections to give
Working with a physician who is frequently involved in medical education on the topic of orthobiologic injections, including PRP
Working with a physician who is transparent and communicative regarding outcomes, expectations and cost
If truth be told, only a few physicians in Middle Tennessee implement all of these details when it comes to PRP injections.
So, if you think you are candidate for this very natural, quite effective, and minimally-invasive treatment, then come see us!
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
Do I Need a Knee Replacement?
/Your 55 year-old knee is hurting and your brain immediately asks the question, “Do I need a knee replacement?”
An x-ray demonstrates moderate to severe osteoarthritis and thus, it’s time for a knee replacement, right? Not necessarily. It’s amazing how many patients have severe findings on their x-rays but minimal to mild pain and excellent function. Therefore, we always say, “Treat the patient, not the x-ray.”
Ok, now your pain has been running 5-7 out of 10 for weeks to months. Therefore, it’s time for a knee replacement, right? Well, pain is certainly a factor in this decision; however, we have many nonsurgical tools in the toolbox that will reduce or eliminate pain for extended periods of time.
Finally, you’ve been episodically limping now for several weeks. You suppose it’s time for a replacement, right? Persistent dysfunction is another reason to have a knee replacement, but function can often be significantly improved without the need for surgery.
To overcome the symptoms and dysfunction of knee arthritis, three factors can be addressed: the environment, the biomechanics and the structure. Only surgery can change the structure, yet significant improvements in the environment and biomechanics can often delay or eliminate the need for knee replacement.
How do we do this? The environment is best changed by injections such as platelet-rich plasma, an anti-inflammatory pattern of eating, supplements and occasionally medications.
The biomechanics can be improved through physical therapy, certain forms of exercise, bracing and changes in footwear.
So in summary, knee replacement can be the right option for many patients and produce successful outcomes in most patients, yet in 80-90% of the patients that walk (or limp) into our office, nonsurgical treatment will be quite effective.
As always, let us know if we can be of assistance to you!
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
When It Comes to Osteoarthritis, PRP is the Winner!
/Although platelet-rich plasma (PRP) injections remain innovative and the science behind and techniques when using them are evolving, they are trending towards the injection of choice, especially in the case of osteoarthritis. Once considered “experimental,” there are now at least 45 studies validating the success of PRP in the treatment of knee osteoarthritis. So simply put, why would you choose PRP over a steroid injection or hyaluronic acid for knee osteoarthritis?
-Safer and more natural
-Longer-lasting relief of pain with often 6 months to 2 years of benefit for knee OA
-Most likely PRP is disease-modifying, meaning it is slowing the deterioration of cartilage in your knee
How about a study or two demonstrating these points made above:
PRP and Knee OA- Article 1
PRP and Knee OA- Article 2
Want to know more? Here are a couple of our previous blogs on the topic:
https://www.impactsportsnashville.com/blog/2024/2/16/7826kg4vvyebmp8bt2aph72i704hmc
https://www.impactsportsnashville.com/blog/2023/6/17/insurance-companies-say-prp-is-experimentalwe-sigh
As always, we are here to help! Let us know if we can be of assistance to you.
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
Proactive Versus Reactive: Which One Are You Choosing?
/We strongly encourage our patients to be proactive with their musculoskeletal health over just being reactive.
Let’s list some examples of the two different approaches:
Proactive
You’re trying to remain in great shape, yet your knee is starting to ache due to mild osteoarthritis. No surgery is necessary, but you want to do something that not only reduces symptoms, but also protects the knee in the long term that is likely disease-modifying. Thus, a series of platelet rich plasma (PRP) injections will meet those goals. PRP injections are one of the best treatment options for the management of osteoarthritis.
You’re starting to have heel pain when you first get out of bed. You suspect plantar fasciitis. Instead of ignoring the symptoms or simply relying on Dr. Google, you decide to consult with a sports medicine physician, so a comprehensive diagnostic and treatment plan can be constructed and customize for you. You realize an inexpensive ultrasound in the office can confirm this diagnosis, determine severity and help with prognosis. At that visit, you’ll be given numerous treatment options and successfully guided on your ability to continue exercising to maintain good health.
You have daily aches and pains, early arthritis and stiffness, but really don’t want to go on daily medications to manage the symptoms. However, you need some help making lifestyle choices as a pertains to diet, supplements and exercise choices. You understand that friends, family, and the Internet are not the optimal resources. Therefore, you decide to move forward with a physician consult so you may receive advice in great detail regarding the best supplements to choose for your particular situation, how to approach exercise and dietary choices. You understand that it is your physician’s to help you decide between what is fact and what is myth.
Reactive
Your heel starts to hurt after some longer walks, especially when you first get out of bed. You talk to friends who recommend rolling the heel, stretching the toes and obtaining non-customized orthotics. You continue to walk, but three months later your heel pain is worse and you limp into the doctor’s office wondering what happened. Bottom line, you now have advanced plantar fasciitis. Unfortunately, the advice you’ve received from well-intentioned others has not been the best for you. Presenting to the doctor when the symptoms first developed would’ve given you a much better outcome, as an entirely different set of treatment options would have been suggested.
Your arthritic knee starts to hurt and you see a bit of swelling, but you decide to keep going to the gym, rubbing Biofreeze on it and you add in some heavy yardwork over several weekends, Ultimately, you can barely bend your very swollen knee, and you’re thinking about canceling that trip to see grandkids. Of course, we are here to help you, but we could’ve avoided this major flare if we would have proactively started some treatment as soon as your knee started to ache.
So we ask the question: are you going to be proactive or reactive? Not every little ache or pain that last hours to a few days should prompt a visit to the doctor. However, do not ignore symptoms and instead, do realize that early treatment usually provides better outcomes than waiting until symptoms rise to a moderate or severe level.
As always, let us know if we can be of assistance to you!
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
PRP: The Simple and Not So Simple
/Many of you are either very familiar or somewhat familiar with platelet-rich plasma injections commonly known as PRP. These are great options for osteoarthritis of a joint, a chronic tendon problem as well as some ligament and fascia problems. Our top conditions treated with PRP include knee osteoarthritis, tennis & golfers’ elbow, plantar fasciitis, rotator cuff tears and Achilles tendon conditions.
When it comes to PRP, here are the simple and not so simple :
Simple
-This is an office procedure, that from start to finish, only takes 45 minutes or less
-A simple blood draw from an arm vein is typically painless
-For a joint injection, pain afterwards is typically very mild
-Risks are exceedingly low as abnormal bleeding, infection, a blood clot or nerve damage are basically nonexistent.
Not So Simple
-We have been performing PRP injections for nearly 15 years. Literally hundreds of hours have been poured into training and fine-tuning the knowledge and skill set it takes to be highly competent to perform this procedure
-Some of our patients have very small veins. Fortunately, we have developed a skill set of ultrasound-guided venipuncture, making blood draws much more successful and less painful on those more challenging patients
-Ultrasound guidance, in our opinion, is a must when giving PRP injections. If you want these growth factor rich platelets to make it to the intended location with great accuracy, then ultrasound guidance is necessary. This is a skill set we have developed over the past 16 years
-With some soft tissue PRP injections, such as partial tears of tendons, we have to prepare our patients that there will be a spike in pain after the procedure, often for one to two weeks. Fortunately, the pain is typically not as significant as it would be if you had a surgery
-Finally, patients have to be patient! PRP exerts its positive effects very gradually. Most patients are seeing a benefit within one to two months, and the maximum benefit often is seen between 6 and 12 months. Thus, we have to advise our patients that with many orthopedic conditions, there is no “quick fix”
Ultimately, PRP can be simple and not so simple, depending on your perspective. Generally speaking, we leave the simple part up to the patient, and we will handle the not so simple aspects of the procedure.
As always, let us know if we can be of assistance to you!
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
I Have Knee Arthritis. Can I Still Run?
/The answer is, “yes,” “maybe” or “no.” Thus, it really depends on your situation, and fortunately, a period of relative rest may only need to be temporary.
Here’s the really good news: several recent studies have indicated that running a reasonable number of miles does not cause knee osteoarthritis and may actually have a protective effect.
If you are a runner and your knee is symptomatic, then our role is to help you reduce or eliminate your symptoms and safely return to running. We know that running has numerous health benefits, not only including protection of the joints, but also calorie burning, weight control, improvement of cardiovascular health and many mental health benefits.
As a patient though, it’s sometimes difficult to know when you need to stop running for a while, what’s a reasonable amount of running for your body and what treatment options may be available to not only reduce your symptoms, but also to protect your knees on a long-term basis.
That’s where we come in! We love treating runners and understand how you think. We typically focus on a nonsurgical and minimally-invasive approach to your care.
Physical therapy, bracing, footwear changes, custom orthotics, medications, supplements, and various injections can all play a role in the treatment of knee osteoarthritis. One of the best long-term treatment options, especially for those with mild to moderate osteoarthritis, would be platelet plasma (PRP) injections. These can have a very protective effect for the knee, and not only by reducing symptoms, but also by slowing or stopping the deterioration of the cartilage within the joint. Only a couple weeks of rest are typically required after these PRP injections.
Check out a few blogs on PRP as well as running as it relates to knee osteoarthritis:
https://www.impactsportsnashville.com/blog/2023/8/5/our-top-5-treatments-for-knee-oa
https://www.impactsportsnashville.com/blog/2023/5/12/five-keys-to-successful-outcomes-with-prp-injections
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36875337/
As always, let us know if we can be of assistance to you!
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
PRP: The Gift of Health
/As we near the major holiday gift-giving season of the year, consider one the best gifts you can give to yourself: the gift of health! Platelet-Rich Plasma (PRP) injections are a great option for you in 2024 if you are looking to boost your orthopedic health and longevity. Here are 5 great adjectives that apply to PRP injections:
1) Safe: adverse effects and complications associated with PRP injections are exceedingly rare.
2) Effective: 80-90% of our patients that receive PRP injections have very good outcomes and are satisfied with their results.
3) Natural: these injections use your blood, specifically your platelets and your growth factors to exert their positive effects.
4) Proven: once considered experimental, there are now hundreds of studies that demonstrate clinical benefit with PRP injections.
5) Preventative: PRP injections are touted in their ability to prevent many degenerative joint and soft conditions from further deterioration.
Want to know more? Check out some of our blogs:
Insurance Companies Say PRP Is Experimental…We Sigh — Impact Sports Medicine & Orthopedics (impactsportsnashville.com)
Five Keys to Successful Outcomes with PRP Injections — Impact Sports Medicine & Orthopedics (impactsportsnashville.com)
PRP And The Three "Es" — Impact Sports Medicine & Orthopedics (impactsportsnashville.com)
As always, let us know if we can be of assistance to you!
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
5 Things You Have to Know If You Have Knee Pain
/1. Three factors play a role in knee pain: structural, biomechanical and environmental. Structural means damage, biomechanical means abnormal tracking or loading within a joint or tendon because of misalignment, weakness, and/or inflexibility. Environmental typically means inflammation within the joint or tendon. When formulating a treatment plan for you, we typically want to address one or two of these factors initially. Unless you have major damage, we’re normally not treating structure initially, as that results in a surgery.
2. Age often plays a role in these different factors: in the absence of injury, in patients under 20 years of age, the problem tends to be biomechanical. In patients ages 20 to 40, the problem tends to be biomechanical and inflammatory. In patients older than 40, structural, biomechanical and inflammatory are typically all playing a role.
3. Being proactive in the care of your knee problem usually produces better outcomes than being reactive. This means integrating treatments early on and not waiting until you have major pain or disability to see a physician. We term this “PIO,” Proactive Interventional Orthopedics.
4. Meniscus tears are commonly found on MRIs and may or may not be a source of pain. For decades, the trend was to treat these surgically, typically arthroscopically, removing the torn piece of meniscus. There’s now a trend towards repairing the meniscus tear when possible, but only about 10% can be successfully repaired. Thus, surgery for meniscus tears, especially those age 40 and above, is falling out of favor. On occasion, surgery is the better choice, but treating these initially nonsurgically is usually the best way to start. We often tell patients “a little torn meniscus is better than less meniscus,” especially long term. Less meniscus often equals greater arthritis.
5. Three types of injections can be used for most knee problems: steroid, hyaluronic acid, and orthobiologics. Orthobiologics include platelet-rich plasma (PRP) and stem cell injections. Each of these injections can be reasonably good choices, but for long-term success, PRP is likely your best option in terms of producing favorable outcomes, modifying the disease process, and these are often the most cost-effective option. Stay away from “stem cell” injections that are ordered by physician’s or chiropractic offices and do not come from you own bone marrow or fat. These are often being used inappropriately, and patients are charged exorbitant amounts of money to have these injections.
As always, let us know if we can be of assistance to you!
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
Our Top 5 Treatments for Knee OA
/Whether it be mild, moderate or severe knee osteoarthritis, here are our top 5 treatments. If you can incorporate these into your regimen, then you undoubtedly will see the benefits of less pain, better function and greater longevity for your knees.
1) Weight Loss: for every 1 pound a person is overweight, an extra 4 pounds of force are going through the knees. So, lose 10 pounds, and you have 40 pounds of less force on those knees. Lose 25 lbs, and 100 fewer lbs. of force! A recent study indicated that when those with knee OA lost 10% of their weight, their pain decreased by 50%
2) Healthy Eating with an Anti-Inflammatory Diet: healthy eating doesn’t always result in weight loss, but choosing the right foods often results in less inflammation in our body. This means less pain and a better environment for the joints. Choose fresh foods over processed ones. Reach for the fresh foods in the refrigerator more than packaged food in the pantry. Eat at home more and go out to restaurants infrequently. Fruits, vegetables, whole grains and lean meats should be the staples of your diet. Alcohol in moderation. Red meat, fried foods and processed food only on occasion and when necessary. Sodas rarely and watch out for artificial sweeteners.
3) Injections: these are often a faster path to relief for most patients. Platelet-rich plasma (PRP) injections utilizing your own blood and concentrated growth factors are the star of this category. Long-term benefits are most common with PRP. Hyaluronic acid injections (brand names: Orthovisc, Trivisc, Gelsyn, Euflexxa, etc.) are good options for many. At times, we combine the PRP and hyaluronic acid injections to boost the benefits. Steroid injections are the final option and can have great utility when a patient needs to feel better quickly such as during a flare or before a big trip.
4) Exercise/Physical Therapy: choose exercise you like, you will stick to, a variety and types that do not cause pain in your knee, both during and afterwards. Sometimes, it’s not just the type of exercise, but the intensity and duration. Find your “sweet spot,” meaning your knee might feel great if you walk a one mile but hurts if you go further. You can bike for 30 minutes, but beyond that causes swelling. So, stay below your pain threshold. Lower-impact options like biking, elliptical, rowing and swimming/aquatic exercises are often the best choices for most with knee OA. Physical therapy is often a good starting point to strengthen the muscles around the joints and to improve biomechanics, functional movement patterns and flexibility.
5) Supplements: our favorites are collagen, curcumin (the active ingredient of turmeric) and for more advanced knee OA, glucosamine and chondroitin. Others like fish oil may have benefits for the joints as well. The key here is choosing a high-quality brand and taking these on daily basis. Admittedly, they don’t help everyone, and you need to make sure that your physician knows you are taking these, especially if you are taking other medications and/or will soon have a medical procedure.
As always, let us know if we can be of assistance to you!
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
Insurance Companies Say PRP Is Experimental…We Sigh
/Platelet-rich plasma (PRP) injections first presented in the orthopedic medical literature in 2004, nearly 20 years ago. Now, new PRP studies hit the orthopedic journals monthly. The overwhelming majority of the evidence suggests that PRP injections are safe, beneficial and have positive effects on soft tissue and joints. Somehow though, insurance companies continue to classify these as “experimental” and will not pay for PRP injections. Thus, these remain cash-pay procedures. PRP injections are not alone, as some of the best procedures now in medicine are not covered by insurance.
PRP is not just used in orthopedics, but also in dentistry, ENT, neurosurgery, ophthalmology, urology, wound healing, cosmetic, hair restoration, cardiothoracic, and maxillofacial surgery. Could all of these specialties be wrong about PRP? I really doubt it.
So, we ask the question: what does it take for something to no longer be classified as experimental? In my opinion, as a physician of 25 years, treatments should no longer be considered experimental if they meet the following basic criteria:
1) They have been used consistently in medicine for 10 years or longer by a reasonably high percentage of specialists in a particular field.
2) Quality studies published in the reputable medical journals demonstrate a clinically significant benefit.
3) Use of a particular treatment steadily grows because of positive results with a low likelihood of adverse events.
If you evaluate PRP with this criteria, then it’s a no-brainer…it is no longer an experimental treatment.
Insurance companies do serve a valuable role in our medical system. Without them, health care would be unaffordable for many Americans. However, the criteria they sometimes use to classify whether a particular treatment or test is covered or not is often very flawed and/or “behind the times.” Here’s a classic example: we could choose to give 10 steroid/cortisone injections into a patient’s knee in just one year, and almost all insurance companies would pay us for each injection. This could be very damaging to the joint, but it would be a “covered” procedure. In contrast, PRP injections, which have been shown to be superior to steroid injections for knee osteoarthritis in dozens of studies, would not be covered by insurance.
So, as a patient, you have to be discerning and partner with a physician who understands what treatment options are best for you. Basing these decisions on what insurance covers can be a short-sighted approach.
In conclusion, both physicians and insurance companies play vital roles in the care of the patient, but these roles are different. I say, “let doctors doctor and administrators administer.” For now, don’t count on a PRP injection to covered by insurance companies any time soon, but that should not deter you from choosing these valuable treatments. Want even more info? Check out one of our recent blogs on the topic:
As always, let us know if we can be of assistance to you.
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
Bet You Didn't Know: Tennis Elbow
/Tennis Elbow, one of the most common conditions seen by an orthopedist, is one our favorite diagnoses to make. Why?…because we are almost always able to see complete resolution of the symptoms. Plus, we have numerous traditional and innovative tools in the toolbox to help our patients overcome this often stubborn and humbling condition. Here are some fast facts about tennis elbow you probably did not know:
-90% of those with tennis elbow, also known as lateral epicondylitis, do not play tennis. Weight-lifting, frequent typing, CrossFit, repetitive labor in one’s work or with household chores are frequent causes.
-Teenagers almost never get tennis elbow. Why? They have an amazing ability for their tendons to recover much faster and more efficiently than middle age and older individuals.
-Lateral epicondylitis is the medical term for tennis elbow and may be one of the more misnamed conditions in orthopedics. This implies there is inflammation of the bone on the outside of the elbow, but instead, this is a tendon problem.
Patients who receive cortisone/steroid injections are often better in the short term but worse in the long term. Our own experience and the medical literature validates this.
Neovascularization, essentially new blood for vessel formation, commonly occurs in advanced cases of tennis elbow. Increased blood flow seems like it would be a good thing for the tendon, but in reality, is a sign of more advanced tendon damage.
We believe that adjacent to those new blood vessels in the tendon are new nerves that are very hypersensitive and only make you feel pain. This is why many patients with advanced cases of tennis elbow complain of “burning” over the lateral elbow.
Platelet-rich plasma injections, now a commonly used and innovative treatment option for many orthopedic conditions, were first studied in the medical literature about 15 years ago in treating tennis elbow. PRP remains one of our advanced treatment options for tennis elbow.
One of our best treatment options for very stubborn cases of tennis elbow is the Tenex procedure. Not many people know about Tenex because we are one of the few physicians in middle Tennessee who have expertise in performing this procedure. We’ve done it for 11 years, and it involves a tiny incision, local anesthesia only, and use of a small needle-like device to excise the unhealthy part of the tendon. No stitches are required and only about two minutes of actual treatment time in the operating room. It carries a 95% success rate in our experience.
If you have pain on the outside of your elbow that is interfering with your quality of life, then come see us. We will have some great options for you!
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
Five Keys to Successful Outcomes with PRP Injections
/Quality Equipment- we’ve chosen a PRP system created by one of the industry’s leaders in orthobiologic injections.. This is our 5th PRP system to use over the past 12 years. Thus, we are always searching for the best option to produce a high-quality PRP solution.
Appropriate Selection of Patients- we attempt to choose patients and conditions that are excellent candidates for PRP injections. Admittedly, not every patient is an ideal candidate, yet their options may be limited in terms of other forms of treatment, or they are willing to have PRP due to its excellent risk-benefit and cost-benefit ratio compared to more invasive treatments. Partial tendon tears, plantar fasciitis and osteoarthritis of the knee, hip and shoulder comprise 95% of our PRP injections.
Appropriate Pre-Procedure and Post-Procedure Instructions and Compliance-little things can be the difference between PRP succeeding or not succeeding or between a good outcome and a great outcome. For example, it’s important for a patient to be off any anti-inflammatories at least a week before and 2 weeks after a PRP injection. It’s also important to rest the treatment area, and this form of rest really varies depending on the patient and their area treated. A patient’s timetable for return to exercise and/or rehabilitation must be carefully outlined.
Quality Preparation of the PRP solution- not all PRP is the same. The platelet concentration and number of platelets can vary and are important aspects of the potential success of PRP. How much blood we take from the patient and the PRP system dictate these numbers. Also, we typically create a leukocyte-poor (low numbers of white blood cells) for joint injections and leukocyte-rich (higher white blood cells and the highest number of platelets) solution for tendon injections.
Accuracy of the Injection, Preferably with Ultrasound Guidance- using ultrasound for the injection often results in less pain, lower risk, and greater accuracy. We place the PRP exactly where it needs to be and avoid hitting other structures like bone, cartilage, nerves and blood vessels. We often say, “if you’re going to invest your time and money in this procedure, don’t you want it done as precisely as possible?”
More medical professionals are performing platelet-rich plasma injections than ever. This innovative treatment is not going away and will only evolve in the years to come. If you think you are a first-time or repeat candidate for a PRP injections, then come see us!
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
Hamstring Strains- The All Too Common Injury
/Picture this….an explosive movement that involves hip flexion and knee extension. What could go wrong? Well, this is the mechanism of a hamstring strain or tear. The classic actions are jumping, kicking, or running. Occasionally, a pop will be felt. We see hamstring strains and tears in our practice often, and frequently, the patient is mistreating their hamstring pathology by the time they get to us. Because of this, we hope this blog will provide education on appropriate first-line treatment before and when you seek medical attention.
First, can anyone name the three hamstring muscles? The answer is: Biceps femoris, semitendinosus, and semimembranosus. What’s the common injury in Major League Baseball: you’re thinking a shoulder or elbow problem, right? Not so fast…a hamstring strain is the most common injury in baseball, and likely the NFL and Major League Soccer as well.
Hamstring strain/tear prevention: proper warm-up, dynamic stretching, adequate rest and recovery, and strengthening. Specifically, the quadriceps muscles tend to get a lot more attention than our hamstrings because they are “look good” muscles. However, neglecting the hamstrings and creating a muscle imbalance definitely increases one’s risks of a hamstring injury. Also in regards to prevention, when a hamstring starts to feel tight or crampy, then that’s a warning sign. It’s then wise to minimize those explosive activities that often lead to a major strain.
In terms of radiographic diagnosis, x-rays are primarily only helpful to evaluate a patient for an avulsion fracture when the pain and strain is near the ischial tuberosity. These fractures are most common in skeletally immature patients such as younger teenagers with open growth plates. Musculoskeletal ultrasound, one of our areas of expertise, is a great and inexpensive way to visualize and grade hamstring strains in our office. Finally, an MRI is the most complete test to visualize a hamstring injury, but is not necessary in most patients and certainly the most expensive and time-consuming test.
Complete tears: If a complete tear is found, particularly proximally (at the origin at the “sit bone”), then surgical reconstruction is the typical treatment. I once knew someone who had liquid courage, (a.k.a., too much alcohol) on board and attempted to do the splits. He made it down into the splits but the explosiveness of the movement caused his hamstring to avulse off of the ischial tuberosity. He had to undergo surgery to reattach it. Needless to say, don’t try to do the splits, folks! Fortunately, complete tears are rare.
Strain/partial tear: This is most commonly the hamstring pathology we see. Hamstring injuries take a long time to heal. With proper treatment, this can be accelerated. The BIGGEST piece of advice I can give initially after the strain is DO NOT STRETCH the hamstring. It will commonly feel tight and feel like you need to stretch, but this will only strain the tendon and muscle belly further. Rest and activity modification are important steps in recovery. This even means to not lead up the stairs with the affected leg or bending at the waist, but instead with at your knees. Any activity that can tug on the hamstring, you should avoid. Other treatment options include thigh sleeve, steroid injection, physical therapy, and platelet-rich plasma (PRP) injections under the guidance of musculoskeletal ultrasound. PRP becomes a great option for proximal hamstring tendon problems that persist beyond a few months. We most commonly see this problem in long distance runners.
Recurrence: hamstring injuries are highly prone to recurrence. This is often due to a return to activity or sport too quickly and/or inadequate rehabilitation. This is why having an expert guide you in your recovery often decreases your risk of re-injury.
In a nutshell, if you have an acute or chronic hamstring injury, it’s best to seek medical attention as opposed to managing this yourself. Proper diagnosis, grading of the strain, discussion of treatment and prevention strategies along with a return-to-play/exercise plan is what we offer our patients.
As always, let us know if we can be of assistance to you!
Taylor Moore, NP and F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
Tiger Woods and You...
/You or someone you know may have something in common with Tiger: plantar fasciitis. Tiger dropped out of the Masters golf tournament last weekend due to severe heel pain caused by plantar fasciitis. This all-too-common orthopedic condition afflicts a huge number of middle-aged Americans every year. The most common symptoms are heel pain when first getting out of bed, when barefoot or with prolonged walking, running or sports. Here are some key “Dos” and “Don’ts” when it comes to plantar fasciitis:
What To Do When You Have Plantar Fasciitis:
1) Seek medical attention early: We have many tools in the toolbox to treat this condition, but we first need to need to confirm the diagnosis, set-up a multi-faceted treatment plan, and guide you on your prognosis. Ultrasound, which can be done in our office, is by far the best imaging study to see the plantar fascia. This factors into our concept of PIO- Proactive Interventional Orthopedics.
2) Wear good footwear at ALL times: when in the house, in the yard, at the gym, at the pool, while shopping, going to that concert, socializing with friends and at church. Good footwear means very supportive, not too flexible, and not too cheap. Cheap unfortunately often means lower quality.
3) Consider inserts/orthotics for your shoes: over-the-counter can get the job done, but you’ll need some advice on how to choose these. A high-quality athletic shoe store or a visit to your sports medicine doctor can supply that information. However, custom orthotics prescribed by your physician may really be what you need. We are fortunate to have custom orthotic specialists that work directly with our practice.
4) Consider physical therapy as it’s beneficial for most patients: many cases of PF are related to biomechanical problems, meaning that your calves are too tight, your foot pronates or supinates, your foot muscles are weak or you are overweight. Physical therapy along with weight loss in some individuals can help correct these biomechanical problems.
5) Realize that 10-20% of cases of PF will need an advanced treatment: in our practice, our first-line innovative and advanced treatment for stubborn PF is a platelet-rich plasma injection. PRP uses your own blood and the concentrated growth factors we have produced to reduce inflammation and pain while stimulating a healing response. If this fails, then we move on to a minimally-invasive surgery called a percutaneous fasciotomy using the Tenex system.
What Not To Do When You Have Plantar Fasciitis:
1) Stretch the bottom of the foot: many cases of PF involve tears in the plantar fascia. Although stretching the calf can help, stretching the bottom of the foot often irritates the fascia and can inhibit the healing process.
2) Buy expensive orthotics that are rigid or produced by an “orthotics store”: in our experience, these tend to be very uncomfortable for patients and unsuccessful in treating patients’ symptoms. Stick with an orthotics specialist recommended by an orthopedic/sports medicine physician.
3) Have multiple steroid/cortisone injections: although offered by some orthopedic doctors and podiatrists, we rarely offer these injections for PF and essentially never do more than one. Steoid injections can contribute to further tearing and often impede healing. Some patients feel better in the short term with steroid injections, but are worse in the long term.
4) Run/Walk through the pain: unfortunately, PF will just not get better if you keep doing the things that are causing the problem. So, a period of complete rest or relative rest will be necessary for PF to improve. Relative rest can mean dialing down your walking/running frequency or distance to the point that you stay below your pain threshold.
5) Become impatient: recovery from PF is often in the range of months, not days or weeks. So, once a treatment plan is in place, you’ll have to be patient. We often construct a Plan A, Plan B and Plan C. Each plan has 2-4 treatment entities within it and we insitute these for 1-2 months, judge their success and then move on to the next plan if we are not seeing the expected results.
In summary, plantar fasciitis is a condition that requires methodical treatment under the care of an experienced physician. Don’t just trust the advice from your non-medical friend, Dr. Google or YouTube. We are always here to help!
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
PRP And The Three "Es"
/This sounds like the name of a band, right? Well, we’re referring to platelet-rich plasma (PRP) injections and three important words that start with an “E” when discussing these procedures.
First, a quick reminder that we use your own blood obtained from an arm vein, a special kit, a centrifuge and a precise separation process to create the PRP. PRP is then a great treatment choice for osteoarthritis of the knee, hip, shoulder and other joints. It’s also an effective treatment for tennis and golfer’s elbow, plantar fasciitis, Achilles and rotator cuff tendon problems, just to name a few. When considering who will perform your PRP injection, you absolutely need to consider the three Es:
Experience: At Impact, Dr. Holmes has been performing PRP injections since 2009. Very few physicians in the Nashville area can claim that level of experience. In addition, we are giving more PRP injections than ever as more and more patients are realizing the benefits of this procedure. Thus, in 2009, we may have given 1-2 PRP injections a month, and now, we give 12-15 a month on average.
Expertise: With experience comes expertise, yet expertise also comes with putting in the work. This means attending conferences, reading and interpreting studies, participating in webinars and interacting with peers who are also experts in the field. Hardly a week goes by that we don’t spend some time fine tuning our expertise in this field. Next, we’ve been pioneers in the sports medicine industry through our ultrasound-guided injections. 14 years of experience with ultrasound and over 10,000 injections later, we consider this to be an area of expertise.
Equipment: PRP is not just PRP, meaning some kits, equipment and the preparation process are better than others. Novices in the field tend to choose lower cost and lower quality PRP systems which often produce fewer numbers and a lower concentration of platelets. At Impact, we are on our 5th PRP system over the past decade. These systems continue to improve, and you deserve a high-quality option. Finally, ultrasound-guidance is paramount when having a PRP injection. Don’t you want this high-powered solution to be injected into the precise location? Without ultrasound guidance, you are proceeding “blindly” and can only hope the injection makes it to the intended location.
Considering a PRP injection for your orthopedic condition? Remember the 3 Es and let us know if we can be of any assistance to you!
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.
Three Common Financial Misconceptions in the Medical World
/Understanding the complexity of various medical expenses can be overwhelming for a patient. We medical professionals are patients too! Even for us, sometimes the numbers just don’t make sense. At Impact Sports Medicine and Orthopedics, our desire is to educate patients regarding the value of these office visits and procedures and their potential out-of-pocket costs, so that they can make informed decisions regarding their health care from both a medical and economic perspective.
Here are three common misconceptions when it comes to medical expenses:
If my physician is not in-network with my insurance company, my medical expenses will be higher: until patients meet their deductibles, they typically will pay out-of-pocket for office visits, diagnostic tests and procedures. The amount a patient pays can also depend on a patient’s out-of-network provisions in their plan and/or the amount an out-of-network provider chooses to bill the patient. Often an out-of-network provider will ask the patient to pay cash, and this amount can be and often is less than the contracted amount an in-network provider has with your insurance. Example: you have Insurance X, a plan that has accepted very few in-network physicians. You have not met your deductible and you see an in-network orthopedic specialist for a consult. You have an office visit and x-rays. Insurance X allows $150 for the office visit and $50 for the x-rays. You now owe that in-network physician $200. Alternatively, you see a provider at our practice as we are in-network with most insurance plans, but not with Insurance X. We charge you $120 for the office visit and $30 for x-rays. Thus, your bill with us is $150, a $50 savings compared to the in-network provider.
If a procedure is not covered by insurance, it will cost me more in the long run: as an example, let’s use a procedure such as a platelet-rich plasma (PRP) injection. PRP has been used in orthopedics for 15 years. It has never been covered by insurance (although it should be in certain circumstances…that’s a whole different conversation). You have stubborn plantar fasciitis. You’ve done all the typical treatments, but your heel still really hurts. You consult with a foot surgeon who offers an open or endoscopic plantar fascia release surgery. Guess what, your insurance covers this procedure! However, you have a $5000 deductible, and you are nowhere near meeting this. This surgery will have charges from the surgery center, the anesthesiologist and the foot surgeon. Let’s say that your total cost for this surgery is $3000 with a 75% success rate, a 4-month recovery and some risk of additional complications. Compare this to one or two PRP injections, with each injection costing you $800. PRP, in our opinion, will have similar success rates and recovery times with fewer complications. $1600 for PRP versus $3000 for the surgery, even though the surgery is “covered by insurance.”
When it comes to an office visit or the same procedure done at different practices, insurance companies pay or allow the same amount for each physician/practice: did you know that all practices, hospitals and other medical businesses have contracted rates of payments with private insurers (non-Medicare, non-Medicaid)? If a physician is part of a bigger organization such as a hospital or a large private practice, then that group typically has greater negotiating power and can obtain higher reimbursement rates from the insurance companies. These rates have nothing to do with the quality of medical care, the training or experience level of the providers or the success rates of their interventions. So, let’s say you see a physician associated with a hospital system. You haven’t met the deductible, and you are billed for a Level 4 new patient visit. Your insurance allows $200 for that visit to that provider. Alternately, your household family member sees a physician at a smaller practice like ours, also is billed for a Level 4 new patient visit, yet the same insurance only allows for $150 for that visit, even though the same level of care was provided. So, you owe $50 more to that hospital-based practice than your family member owes to the smaller private practice. Thus, it’s important to realize that often cost really does vary based on who you are seeing, and your cost is not associated with the quality of the care.
At Impact Sports Medicine, cost education and financial transparency are very important to the physician-patient relationship. We strive to provide the highest quality of care for a reasonable out-of-pocket cost to you.
F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.