“Blood” (PRP) Versus “Gel” (Hyaluronic Acid) Injections: How to Choose

The two most popular and common injections we offer patients for knee osteoarthritis are platelet-rich plasma (PRP), utilizing a patient’s own blood, and hyaluronic acid injections, commonly known as the gel, rooster comb, or viscosupplement injections.

Let’s compare the two and discuss pros and cons of each:

Both would be considered “natural“ injections with PRP obviously coming from your own blood and hyaluronic acid is a substance already in your joint, but depleted in joints that have osteoarthritis.

We often describe PRP as that big 100,000 mile service you do on your car, and hyaluronic injections are more like the oil change. Thus, PRP is more comprehensive.

PRP Injections

PROS

-most effective long-term injection we offer patients. Benefits typically seen for 6–24 months, and then PRP can then be safely repeated when necessary.

-very likely disease–modifying, meaning we are stopping or slowing the deterioration of cartilage in the knee. These give patients the greatest opportunity to either delay or avoid knee replacement.

-other than weight loss, probably the best long-term medical and financial nonsurgical investment in the health of your knee.

CONS

-not covered by insurance. See our blog regarding this here

-works gradually, with greatest benefit likely seen 4-6 months after the injections.

-anti-inflammatories of any type as well as blood thinners need to be stopped before and after the PRP procedure for a specific period of time.

Hyaluronic acid Injections

PROS

-authorized by most insurance plans, meaning the cost of these is fully covered, partially covered, or can be applied towards your deductible.

-excellent safety profile.

-the majority of patients see a benefit, often for 4 to 12 months.

-like PRP, injections are not particularly painful when given into the knee joint under ultrasound guidance and only require a few days of rest afterwards.

CONS

-may have an indirect benefit on the long-term health of the knee joint, but are not considered “disease–modifying” like PRP.

-benefits of pain and swelling reduction along with functional improvements do not last as long as PRP.

-although they work a bit more rapidly than PRP injections, typically it takes 6 to 8 weeks after the final injection to see the greatest benefit.

-most brands require a series of 3–4 total injections, given one per week.

Want to know more about PRP?

Learn about the key details of PRP here

How is PRP simple and not-so-simple? Read here

As always, let us know if we can be of assistance to you!

F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.

Our Top 5 Treatments for Knee OA

Whether it be mild, moderate or severe knee osteoarthritis, here are our top 5 treatments. If you can incorporate these into your regimen, then you undoubtedly will see the benefits of less pain, better function and greater longevity for your knees.

1) Weight Loss: for every 1 pound a person is overweight, an extra 4 pounds of force are going through the knees. So, lose 10 pounds, and you have 40 pounds of less force on those knees. Lose 25 lbs, and 100 fewer lbs. of force! A recent study indicated that when those with knee OA lost 10% of their weight, their pain decreased by 50%

2) Healthy Eating with an Anti-Inflammatory Diet: healthy eating doesn’t always result in weight loss, but choosing the right foods often results in less inflammation in our body. This means less pain and a better environment for the joints. Choose fresh foods over processed ones. Reach for the fresh foods in the refrigerator more than packaged food in the pantry. Eat at home more and go out to restaurants infrequently. Fruits, vegetables, whole grains and lean meats should be the staples of your diet. Alcohol in moderation. Red meat, fried foods and processed food only on occasion and when necessary. Sodas rarely and watch out for artificial sweeteners.

3) Injections: these are often a faster path to relief for most patients. Platelet-rich plasma (PRP) injections utilizing your own blood and concentrated growth factors are the star of this category. Long-term benefits are most common with PRP. Hyaluronic acid injections (brand names: Orthovisc, Trivisc, Gelsyn, Euflexxa, etc.) are good options for many. At times, we combine the PRP and hyaluronic acid injections to boost the benefits. Steroid injections are the final option and can have great utility when a patient needs to feel better quickly such as during a flare or before a big trip.

4) Exercise/Physical Therapy: choose exercise you like, you will stick to, a variety and types that do not cause pain in your knee, both during and afterwards. Sometimes, it’s not just the type of exercise, but the intensity and duration. Find your “sweet spot,” meaning your knee might feel great if you walk a one mile but hurts if you go further. You can bike for 30 minutes, but beyond that causes swelling. So, stay below your pain threshold. Lower-impact options like biking, elliptical, rowing and swimming/aquatic exercises are often the best choices for most with knee OA. Physical therapy is often a good starting point to strengthen the muscles around the joints and to improve biomechanics, functional movement patterns and flexibility.

5) Supplements: our favorites are collagen, curcumin (the active ingredient of turmeric) and for more advanced knee OA, glucosamine and chondroitin. Others like fish oil may have benefits for the joints as well. The key here is choosing a high-quality brand and taking these on daily basis. Admittedly, they don’t help everyone, and you need to make sure that your physician knows you are taking these, especially if you are taking other medications and/or will soon have a medical procedure.

As always, let us know if we can be of assistance to you!

F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.

It’s Time To Start Treating Your Arthritic Knee Like Your Car

“Orthopedic Maintenance”…that’s a term you may start to hear, especially in our practice. For years, patients have been led to believe that in the case of their arthritis, there’s “nothing you can do about it” until you want or choose to have a replacement. Also, our medical system has been developed to be reactive instead of proactive, especially again in the setting of arthritis. So, let me ask you this, do you only take your car to the mechanic when you have a problem? If the answer is yes, then you are on the fast track to either a needing a new car or paying your mechanic a pretty penny for all the repairs your car will need! If you are a wise car owner, then you take your car in at regular intervals for the oil change, fluid additions, tire rotation, alignment, brake maintenance and various inspections. So I then ask, should you be doing the same for your arthritic knee? The answer is a resounding “Yes!”

So, what does orthopedic maintenance look like? In very general terms, it means that if your body has aches, pains or dysfunction, then it’s wise to jump on these earlier than later, avoiding the temptation to ignore symptoms, and think, “I’m just getting old.” This translates to seeing your orthopedic/sports medicine physician to confirm a diagnosis and discuss treatment and prevention strategies. Let’s focus on one of the most effective forms of non-operative treatment for knee osteoarthritis: injections

1)     Steroid (cortisone) injections are great for acute pain, when it’s important to reduce symptoms and swelling quickly. Steroids are really a more “reactive” treatment, such as when a patient needs to feel better quickly for a major life event (a trip, visit with the grandkids, have to feel better for work, etc.) but can be proactive for a patient trying to stave off a knee replacement or is not a good candidate for knee replacement. For example, the elderly patient whose risk of knee replacement outweighs the benefit, planning two steroid injections a year for his/her symptomatic knee arthritis may allow the patient to feel less pain, move better, be at lower risk for a fall and have a greater quality of life.

2)     Hyaluronic Acid/Viscosupplement injections (brand names include Orthovisc, Gelsyn, Euflexxa, etc.) have a long track record of excellent safety and provide symptomatic relief in approximately 75% of patients for 4-12 months. They probably work as anti-inflammatories and lubricants for the knee, replenishing the hyaluronic acid in the arthritic knee that is depleted or less effective. These are probably more beneficial for those with mild to moderate arthritis as opposed to more severe cases. There are essentially no side effects except for mild injection-site soreness in some. Most insurance companies will authorize this 3-4 injection series every 6 months, so planning on about two series a year is a very proactive strategy. These are what we often term as the “oil change” injections.

3)     Orthobiologic injections are really your “game-changer” injections. These have been used in orthopedics for 15 years and in our practice for over 10 years. Platelet-Rich Plasma (PRP) is the most commonly used orthobiologic injection. Insurance companies and even some medical providers still like to consider these as “experimental” or unproven treatments for osteoarthritis, yet there are now 39 randomized, controlled trials (studies) that demonstrate that PRP is effective in the treatment of knee osteoarthritis. PRP is derived from your own blood, as we obtain blood from an arm vein, spin this in a centrifuge, remove the majority of red and white blood cells, and concentrate the platelets which are rich in your own growth factors. These growth factors module inflammation, reduce pain, improve function, and most likely have a beneficial effect on the cartilage within the joint. This is how they are “game-changers.” They very likely stop or slow the progression of arthritis by stabilizing the cartilage and potentially improving the quality of the cartilage.

We typically start with two PRP injections 2-6 weeks apart and expect, on the average, 6-12 months of symptomatic benefit. Repeating these at regular intervals is likely the best plan of action in order to see continued, long-term benefits. PRP injections are here to stay, and how we continue to apply them in the treatment of osteoarthritis will continue to evolve.

Primary care providers and dentists have done a great job integrating maintenance evaluations and treatments into a patient’s health regimen. Now, we should likely be doing the same in orthopedics, and the treatment of knee osteoarthritis is a great place to start, as this is the most common medical condition seen in our office today. It is a tremendous source of pain and disability for millions of Americans and contributes to the spending of billions of health care dollars. It’s time for orthopedic physicians and patients to join together to be proactive over reactive and realize that less-invasive preventative strategies are preferred over more-invasive and costly interventions.

As always, we here to help and strive to be your resource for these innovative maintenance strategies!

F. Clarke Holmes, M.D.

Impact Sports Medicine and Orthopedics